How to Collect Emails for Email Marketing: Top 16 Strategies

Imagine if every dollar you invested in marketing returned $70 in profit. Sounds too good to be true, right? But before you assume we’re pitching a Ponzi scheme, hear us out—because this is exactly what effective email marketing can achieve.

In this guide, we’ll walk you through the strategies that allow businesses to achieve massive returns through email marketing without spending an extra penny. But there’s one crucial ingredient for success: an engaged email list. Without it, even the best email campaigns won’t drive results.

That’s why we’re sharing 16 proven email acquisition strategies that will help you grow your list and maximize your marketing ROI. From high-converting pop-ups to advanced website visitor identification, these tactics will help you capture more leads—even from shoppers who don’t complete a purchase.

Here’s what we’ll cover:

• How much an email address is worth and why it’s one of your most valuable assets.
• Why email marketing is critical for your business’s success.
• 16 powerful tactics to build your email list, including an innovative method that allows you to capture visitors’ email addresses—even if they never fill out a form.
• How LeadPost can enhance email acquisition, helping you identify and engage potential customers more effectively.

By the end of this guide, you’ll have the tools and knowledge to build a thriving email list, create stronger customer relationships, and generate more revenue through email marketing.

Main Takeaways

• Email marketing delivers high ROI. On average, businesses earn $42 for every $1 spent on email marketing, making it one of the most profitable digital marketing channels.
• A strong email list is essential for success. Without an engaged list of subscribers, even the best email campaigns won’t generate results. Effective email acquisition ensures you have a steady stream of leads to nurture and convert.
• Diversify your email collection methods. Use multiple strategies such as pop-ups, lead magnets, landing pages, social media promotions, and website visitor identification to capture emails from different touchpoints.
• Quality over quantity matters. A clean, engaged email list is more valuable than a large, unresponsive one. Follow best practices like double opt-ins, segmentation, and list hygiene to maintain deliverability and engagement.
• LeadPost enhances email acquisition. Advanced tools like LeadPost help businesses capture emails from anonymous website visitors, increasing list growth without relying solely on opt-in forms.

What is an Email Address Worth to Your Business?

Email marketing remains one of the most profitable channels for businesses, delivering a remarkable return on investment (ROI). According to a Data & Marketing Association study, marketing professionals report an average return of $67.87 for every dollar spent on B2C email marketing—an increase of over $14 from previous reports, proving that email is far from obsolete.

Additionally, 71% of marketers are now confidently tracking the impact of their email campaigns, reinforcing the value of email marketing. On average, each email address is worth $52.31, factoring in both B2B and B2C businesses. However, B2C companies report a slightly higher lifetime value of $57.97 per email.

In the e-commerce space, email value varies depending on the platform:

• Shopify Core merchants generate an average return of $16.53 per email.
• Shopify Plus merchants—who typically serve higher-volume businesses—see an even greater return of $22.82 per email.

With such strong ROI, email acquisition isn’t just a strategy—it’s an essential investment that directly impacts revenue growth. By implementing the right email collection methods, businesses can turn website visitors into long-term, high-value customers.

The Importance of Email Acquisition for Email Marketing Campaigns

The return on investment can’t be ignored, but that’s not the only benefit of email marketing. Successful email acquisition is vital for your business and your email marketing campaigns. Here’s why:

Cost Effectiveness

Sending emails is much more affordable than other channels like digital advertising. You can even get started for free with an email service provider like HubSpot. The more emails you acquire, the more value you get from email marketing.

You Own Your Email List

Unlike your Facebook or Instagram followers, you own your email list. When you acquire an email, you don’t have to worry about organic reach or changes to Google’s algorithm. If you keep your email list healthy and protect your deliverability and IP reputation, you can contact everyone on your list at any time.

Customers Prefer Email for Contact from Brands

The customer is always right, and over half of them say they prefer brands to contact them by email. (Social media is the next best channel at a minuscule 25%.) Email acquisition allows you to interact with potential customers in the way they prefer.

Email Helps Build Relationships

Email marketing allows you to send targeted campaigns to the right people at the right time in a way that improves your brand reputation and keeps your company top-of-mind. When you acquire an email, you’re giving yourself to ability to establish an ongoing relationship with people who are interested in your products or services.

Personalized Content is King

Personalized emails allow businesses to deliver relevant, targeted messages that resonate with individual subscribers, increasing engagement and conversions. By leveraging customer data—such as purchase history, browsing behavior, and preferences—brands can craft emails that feel tailored to each recipient, making them more likely to open, click, and take action.

Studies show that personalized email campaigns drive higher open rates, click-through rates, and revenue, proving that generic, one-size-fits-all messaging is no longer effective in today’s competitive landscape.

How to Collect Email Addresses Effectively: 16 Methods

Building a high-quality email list requires a multi-channel approach to capture potential subscribers at different touchpoints in their customer journey.

By leveraging a mix of on-site, social media, and offline strategies, businesses can maximize email acquisition while ensuring they attract engaged and interested leads who are more likely to convert.

1. Use Pop-Ups on Your Website

Everyone loves to hate pop-up forms, but it’s hard to argue with their results. Sumo studied the results of 1,754,957,675 pop-ups and found that the average conversion rate for these bothersome little forms is 3.1%. Top-performing pop-up ads saw a conversion rate of 9.28%.

Even if you only receive mediocre results and your website traffic is on the low side at, say, 1,000 visitors a month, that’s 30 new email addresses for your list each month. If an email address is worth $16, that’s an additional $500 a month just for adding some JavaScript to your website.

This is one of the easiest email acquisition tactics we’ll cover. And since there are so many free pop-up form providers to choose from, it’s 100% profit.

2. Add Sign-Up Forms to Your Homepage

Your homepage is one of the most visited pages on your website, making it a prime location for collecting email addresses.

A well-placed sign-up form—either in the header, footer, or as an inline section—ensures visitors can easily subscribe without navigating away. Keep the form simple by only asking for essential information like an email address and first name to reduce friction. Pair it with a compelling incentive, such as a discount, free resource, or exclusive updates, to encourage more sign-ups.

3. Leverage Contact Pages

Your contact page is often used by visitors who want to engage with your business, making it a great opportunity to collect emails.

By adding an optional email opt-in checkbox to your contact form, you can encourage inquiries to subscribe to your list. Instead of just receiving a reply to their inquiry, they’ll also be added to your newsletter, promotions, or product updates, keeping them engaged with your brand. This passive yet effective approach ensures you’re capturing leads from people already interested in your business.

4. Create Irresistible Lead Magnets

Lead magnets offer something of value in exchange for an email address, making them one of the most effective ways to grow your list. Examples include ebooks, whitepapers, free templates, exclusive reports, checklists, or webinars that solve a specific problem for your target audience.

The key is to make the lead magnet highly relevant and actionable, ensuring subscribers feel they’re getting something genuinely useful. Well-crafted lead magnets not only increase sign-ups but also attract higher-quality leads who are more likely to engage with your emails.

5. Use Landing Pages for Sign-Ups

Dedicated landing pages convert at higher rates because they are designed with a single goal—getting visitors to sign up. Unlike generic website pages, a well-optimized landing page includes a strong headline, compelling benefits, a clear call-to-action, and minimal distractions to drive conversions.

Whether you’re promoting a webinar, an exclusive discount, or a free resource, sending traffic to a dedicated landing page ensures visitors focus solely on subscribing. Pairing these pages with paid ads, SEO, or social media campaigns can amp up your email acquisition efforts.

6. Create Engaging Social Media Posts

Social media is an excellent lead generation tool that allows you to capture emails from followers who already engage with your brand.

By sharing posts that promote exclusive offers, gated content, or giveaways, you can drive traffic to sign-up forms and landing pages. Running polls, asking questions, and sharing behind-the-scenes content also helps spark engagement, making it easier to organically grow your list.

Platforms like Instagram, LinkedIn, and Facebook offer built-in CTA buttons (e.g., “Sign Up” or “Learn More”) that direct users straight to your email collection page.

7. Use Paid Advertising on Social Media Platforms

Paid social media ads allow you to target specific audiences and quickly grow your email list with high-quality leads. Facebook and Instagram Ads, for example, let you create lead generation forms that users can fill out without leaving the platform.

LinkedIn and YouTube also offer lead capture ad formats that help you collect emails from professionals or video viewers. With detailed audience targeting options, you can reach potential subscribers based on their demographics, interests, and behaviors, ensuring you’re capturing emails from people most likely to engage with your business.

8. Leverage Events and Webinars

Hosting live events or webinars is an excellent way to provide value while capturing email addresses. Attendees must register with their email before they can access the event, ensuring you’re collecting highly engaged leads.

After the webinar, you can follow up with replay links, additional resources, and exclusive offers, keeping your new subscribers engaged. Collaborating with industry influencers or partners can expand your reach, bringing in even more sign-ups from new audiences.

9. Add Opt-In Forms to Your 404 Page

A 404 error page is typically a dead end, but you can turn it into a lead generation opportunity by adding an email sign-up form. Instead of just displaying an apology for a broken link, offer visitors an incentive to subscribe, such as a discount, free guide, or exclusive content.

A friendly message like, “Oops! Looks like this page is missing—why not sign up for our newsletter and get valuable updates instead?” can turn lost visitors into leads.

10. Run Contests or Giveaways

Running contests and giveaways is a powerful way to drive email sign-ups, especially on social media. By offering a prize that aligns with your audience’s interests, such as a free product, service, or gift card, you encourage people to enter by providing their email address.

Tools like Rafflecopter, KingSumo, and Gleam allow you to set up viral giveaways where participants earn bonus entries for sharing, expanding your reach. Just ensure your prize attracts your ideal customers rather than people who sign up only for freebies.

11. Try Chatbots or Messenger Apps

Chatbots and messenger apps provide a direct way to collect emails while engaging with visitors in real-time. Automated chatbots can prompt users with a personalized message, offering help or exclusive content in exchange for an email address.

Messenger apps like Facebook Messenger or WhatsApp allow businesses to build email lists by collecting contact details during conversations. Since chatbot interactions feel natural and interactive, they often result in higher engagement and opt-in rates.

12. Promote Signups in Your Email Signature

Your email signature is prime real estate for promoting your newsletter, and it’s an easy way to collect new subscribers.

Adding a simple CTA like “Join our exclusive email list for updates and special offers!” with a link to your sign-up page ensures that every email you send becomes an opportunity to grow your list. This tactic works especially well for customer support, sales, and networking emails, helping turn everyday communication into a lead generation tool.

13. Offer Special Discounts to New Subscribers

Nothing incentivizes sign-ups quite like a discount for first-time subscribers. Many e-commerce brands offer 10–20% off to new customers who join their email list, creating an immediate value exchange.

This approach reduces friction, as visitors feel like they’re getting a deal just for subscribing. To encourage repeat purchases, consider combining discounts with a loyalty program or exclusive perks for long-term engagement.

14. Capture Emails on the Add to Cart Page

One of the best moments to collect emails is when customers show intent to buy—and the add-to-cart page is the perfect place for it. Since most of shopping carts are abandoned, capturing an email at this stage allows you to follow up with reminders, exclusive discounts, or limited-time offers to bring customers back.

You can implement a mandatory email field before adding an item to the cart or use an exit-intent pop-up when users try to leave. With cart abandonment emails averaging open rates above 40%, this tactic can significantly boost conversions.

15. Start a Referral Program

Referral programs incentivize your existing subscribers to bring in new leads, making them one of the most effective email acquisition strategies.

Newsletters like Morning Brew and The Hustle have used referral programs to scale to millions of subscribers by rewarding users for each successful referral. You can set up milestone-based rewards, where subscribers get discounts, freebies, or VIP access based on how many friends they refer. This approach not only helps grow your list organically but also brings in highly engaged leads, as people trust recommendations from friends.

16. Use Website Visitor Identification

Most website visitors never fill out a form, meaning businesses miss out on thousands of potential leads. Website visitor identification tools like LeadPost solve this problem by identifying up to 40% of anonymous visitors and converting that data into verified names, emails, and mailing addresses.

This method allows you to capture and nurture leads who would have otherwise left without engaging. Since email marketing delivers one of the highest ROIs in digital marketing, this approach ensures you maximize your website traffic and boost revenue without relying solely on form submissions.

Seven Email Collection Best Practices

Collecting email addresses ethically and compliantly ensures that your list remains engaged, effective, and legally sound. By following best practices, businesses can build trust with subscribers, improve email deliverability, and maximize marketing performance without risking penalties or damaging their brand reputation.

1. Prioritize Quality Over Quantity

Buying email lists might seem like a shortcut to rapid growth, but it often results in low engagement, high unsubscribe rates, and spam complaints, which can damage your sender reputation. Instead, prioritize organic list-building strategies, ensuring that subscribers genuinely want to hear from you, leading to higher open rates and conversions.

2. Ensure Compliance

Strict email marketing regulations like GDPR, CAN-SPAM, and CASL require businesses to obtain explicit consent before sending emails, protecting consumers from spam. Following these laws not only prevents hefty fines but also fosters trust with your audience, improving deliverability and long-term engagement.

3. Use Double Opt-Ins

A double opt-in process—where users confirm their subscription via email—helps verify that sign-ups are legitimate and interested in receiving your content. This extra step reduces fake or mistyped email addresses, ensuring your list remains high quality and engaged.

4. Segment Your List

Effective email marketing isn’t one-size-fits-all—segmenting your list by behavior, demographics, or interests allows you to send more targeted and relevant messages. This personalization increases engagement, reduces unsubscribes, and boosts conversion rates by ensuring recipients receive content that resonates with them.

5. Maintain List Hygiene

Regularly cleaning your email list by removing inactive subscribers, correcting invalid addresses, and suppressing bounced emails helps maintain a healthy sender reputation. Keeping your list clean improves email deliverability, prevents spam complaints, and ensures your messages reach engaged recipients.

6. Never Buy Lists

Purchased email lists contain unverified, uninterested, and potentially spam-trap email addresses, leading to low engagement and high spam complaints. Instead, focus on permission-based email collection, ensuring that everyone on your list has actively opted in, improving campaign performance and brand credibility.

7. Optimize for Mobile

Many people read emails on mobile devices, so ensuring your emails are mobile-friendly is essential for engagement. Use responsive design, concise subject lines, and easy-to-click CTAs to provide a seamless experience that prevents frustration and improves conversions.

Grow Your Email List with LeadPost’s Visitor Identification Tools

A strong email list is the foundation of every successful email marketing campaign, but traditional methods only capture a fraction of your website visitors.

LeadPost’s visitor identification software changes the game by allowing you to collect emails from up to 40% of anonymous website visitors, even if they don’t fill out a form. This means more leads, higher engagement, and increased revenue—without extra ad spend.

Don’t miss out on potential customers. Try LeadPost for free and start turning website visitors into valuable email subscribers today!

Try LeadPost for Free

FAQs